Isaac Butterworth has served as pastor of First Presbyterian Church since 1989, when he and his wife, Jan, moved to Wichita Falls with their two children. Ike, as he is known to most people, is a graduate of Baylor University (B.A., 1968), Southwestern Seminary (M.Div., 1972), and McCormick Theological Seminary (D. Min., 1980). He also studied at Southern Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky, and at Austin Seminary in Austin, Texas. Ike served as a pastor in Holland, Levelland, and Vernon, all cities in Texas, prior to coming to Wichita Falls.
Samuel Weems has served as pastor of First Presbyterian Church since 2016, when he and his wife, Benita, moved to Wichita Falls with their two children, Ezra and Sophia. Samuel is a graduate of Rhodes College (B.A., 2002) and Reformed Theological Seminary (M.Div., 2008). Samuel served as Youth Director of College Park Presbyterian Church in Orlando and Associate Pastor at Trinity Wellsprings Church in Satellite Beach, Florida prior to coming to Wichita Falls.